image copyrightGetty Images

On February 24, 2022, hours after declaring an all-out invasion of Ukraine, Russian President Vladimir Putin gathered his country's wealthiest men into the Kremlin's massive Yekaterinsky Hall.

About 30 businessmen wearing masks due to the COVID-19 pandemic were sitting huddled together along one wall. A Russian newspaper reporter described their appearance as "pale-faced and as if they were suffering from lack of sleep."

After a while, Putin entered the conference hall and sat alone on the other side, far away from them. He sat across from us across a wide space and, as usual, did not wear a mask.

And in a unique, indirect way, he asked businessmen to support this war.

“We hope you understand what is happening,” he said, adding, “Please cooperate with the government to find ways to support production, the economy, and jobs.”

In the video of the meeting released by the Kremlin, none of the invited billionaires spoke.

Such silence has suddenly become a natural characteristic of Russian conglomerates. This is because, after decades of Putin’s rule, they realized that raising their voices could cost them a lot.

In 2003, oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Russia's richest man at the time and funding several opposition groups, criticized Putin for turning a blind eye to rampant corruption.

End of TOP News

He was later convicted of tax evasion, fraud, and embezzlement and spent 10 years in prison. Khodorkovsky denied the charges, but this may have been a clear warning to other potential critics.

image copyrightALEXEY NIKOLSKY/SPUTNIK/AFP via Getty Images

Even if there were some of the conglomerates gathered there who opposed the war, they would not have been able to reveal their true intentions.

But even in that silence, whispers leak out. Some of Russia's once powerful business elite seem to be imagining a post-Putin era.

They wonder whether, if the president steps down or dies, we will return to the days of the 1990s when oligarchs enjoyed power, or whether a healthier political system will take shape.

Arkady Ostrovsky, a prominent Kremlin expert for The Economist who recently interviewed one of Russia's richest men for several hours, says he senses "a historic and political change is taking place" in the way the ultra-rich view the country's future.

Uptight oligarchs.

With the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, a new and powerful power emerged in Russia. These are businessmen who took advantage of the end of communism to accumulate enormous wealth and then took over political power for their own benefit.

The world began to call them 'oligarchy', a word derived from the Greek word oligarchy, which means oligarchy, a system in which a few monopolize power. They had money, and at the time, money meant power.

In this chaotic era of the 90s, a large number of new wealthy people called 'New Russians' emerged. Huge state-owned companies were put up for sale, and if you had the right connections, you could become a millionaire, or even a billionaire, almost overnight. Corruption and nepotism were rampant, and even contract killings were frequent.

However, Putin, who became president in 2000, immediately began suppressing the oligarchs. He had no intention of sharing power with anyone else.

Moreover, at the time, the Russian economy was revitalizing and the power of the central government was growing stronger, so there was room to stand up to billionaires.

image copyrightNurPhoto/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Bill Browder, a financier who was once the largest foreign investor in Russia but was banned from entering Russia in 2005 after campaigning against corruption, explained that Russian businessmen are very scared of Putin.

For example, it is said that this was the case at the 'Davos Economic Forum', which was still welcomed in the Western world even before the Ukraine war.

In an interview with the BBC, he recalled, "I remember the oligarchs strutting around as if it was their house. They were really arrogant and confident. Then Putin came along, and the powerful alpha males, who seemed to have been on steroids, became very obedient. They turned into students who were desperately trying to impress their teacher. It was an amazing sight."

Since the outbreak of war in 2022, the Kremlin has been controlling its country's wealthy through a ruthless 'carrot and stick' strategy.

Those who criticized the war were stripped of their property, while those who declared loyalty were rewarded with lucrative war-related contracts. Today, there are more billionaires in Russia than ever before (155 in total, according to Forbes magazine), and their total assets are at an all-time high, approaching $700 billion.

But even the tycoons who pledged their loyalty and were rewarded for it seem not able to buy happiness with that much money. Some are increasingly showing signs of anxiety and nervousness.

End of content

Dictatorship, oligarchy, or democracy?

Their multi-billion dollar fortunes aren't as powerful as they used to be. First of all, it is difficult to acquire political influence within Russia.

As exiled Russian politician and analyst Dmitry Nekrasov put it, "They have no cards to play, no games to play."

“They got rich because of their connections with Putin, not because they were rich.”

What about outside of Russia? They are being marginalized due to sanctions imposed by the West following Russia's full-scale invasion.

Browder, who has publicly criticized Putin to this day, explained, "They are treated like petty criminals. They can't take private jets, they can't sail yachts and dock at famous European ports. It must be a truly terrible and humiliating thing for them."

So some oligarchs have quietly begun to think about the post-Putin situation. That's what multiple sources familiar with the world of these giants have told me.

Of course, there is no prospect that Putin will step down anytime soon, and there is no reason to believe that his health is poor. But Putin, who turned 74 last month, has ruled the Kremlin for 25 years, and people in Moscow know that one day he will step down.

When asked by Reuters last year whether he intended to remain in office until 2036, when his constitutional term technically ends, Putin responded, "Only God knows whether my health will hold up until then."

image copyrightCARL DE SOUZA/AFP via Getty Images

If Putin resigns or dies while in office, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin will take over. But Prime Minister Mishustin has never shown any ambitions for the presidency (which is probably why he was appointed prime minister).

Then there will be a kind of power vacuum.

Russian experts I spoke with suggested several possible scenarios.

Some in the Western world, as well as within Russia, hope that after Putin, Russia will be reborn as a democracy rather than returning to an oligarchy where oligarchs exercise power or welcoming another dictator.

But analysts say this is the least likely scenario. During Putin's rule, major democratic institutions were damaged or collapsed. As exiled Russian journalist and analyst Alexandra Prokopenko put it, "Russia has become too accustomed to violence. Ordinary democratic processes have become foreign."

Another scenario is a continuation of the dictatorship. A new figure emerges to replace Putin and continue his oppressive rule.

However, Prokopenko believed that a strong dictator would not emerge, at least not immediately. Whoever Putin's successor is, he will initially have a weaker power base and fewer resources, as building up power takes time.

And the third scenario is a return to a form close to the 90s-style oligarchic system, with oligarchs once again seizing power.

Necrasop predicted that in this case, a few powerful elite business families would collude to control the country.

Of course, this last scenario may be the future most desired by many oligarchs. “They want to go back to a time when their voices were heard, when their assets weren’t confiscated, when they understood the rules of the game,” said Prokopenko, who has spent years talking to Russia’s richest people.

Although their power has weakened significantly since the 1990s, it is still necessary to listen to the wishes of oligarchs. Since he still holds enormous wealth, he may soon seek to regain political influence.

Nekrasov, a politician in exile, said some are already "moving to build relationships with high-ranking security officials and ministers." But any further action is said to be “too dangerous.”

image copyrightVladimir Smirnov SPUTNIK/KREMLIN POOL/EPA/Shutterstock

Nekrasov analyzed that the oligarchs' actions in the coming years will depend on their financial situation. Those with more liquid capital will be more confident in “playing the political game,” strengthening their positions, and preparing for a post-Putin world, but those whose fortunes depend on government contracts or government favors are less likely to step forward for fear of losing everything.

Meanwhile, Prokopenko says there has already been a change in the way wealthy people talk about Putin. In the past, he was referred to as 'Nachalik' (meaning 'boss') or 'Pervi' ('first'), or by 'VV', the initials of his first name and patronymic, all of which conveyed a degree of respect.

But now they call him 'Ded', a title that Prokopenko says is not only less respectful but also "slightly dismissive." ‘Dead’ means ‘old man’ or ‘grandfather’.

Prokopenko said some of Russia's richest people are longing for what he calls the "routinization of politics," with less repression, greater freedom of speech and healthier competition between political parties and politicians.

However, it is said that they are currently unable to dare to take action due to the suffocating atmosphere. For example, Prokopenko interviewed a tycoon who sat directly on his phone throughout the conversation, saying he would prevent digital eavesdropping by the secret police.

Prokopenko added, “It was a fear completely reminiscent of the Stalin era. Isn’t it truly irrational?”

bombshell interview

Meanwhile, a clue as to what Russian tycoons want in the post-Putin future can be found in Andrey Melnichenko, the 8th richest person in Russia, known as the 'global fertilizer king'.

Earlier this year, he surprised observers by giving an interview to Britain's The Economist. It is very rare for Russia's wealthy to talk to media outlets, even those in countries the Kremlin regards as hostile. ‘The Economist’ also published an essay he wrote.

Of course, in the interview Melnichenko repeated the Kremlin's claims. He called Ukraine a battleground between Russia and the West and said he believed the West was ignoring Russia's security concerns and threatening its sovereignty.

But the interesting part started after that. Although he did not directly call for Putin's resignation, Melnichenko implied that changes were needed to end one-man rule in Russia. He also said that Russia should engage more actively with the world.

Prokopenko believes that Melnichenko was trying to spark public discussion through these interviews. It was said to be a signal “urging the wealthy like themselves to speak out.”

Reporter Ostrovsky, who interviewed him, said that he and Melnichenko "drank coffee mainly in hotels and cafes. They drank a lot of coffee, smoked cigarettes, and had tense and intense discussions." And Melnichenko says he appeared to be "seriously considering" the question rather than embellishing his words like a politician.

Nothing is simple in Russia, and most observers believe this interview was conducted with implicit or explicit approval from the Kremlin. However, it is unknown why the Russian authorities allowed this unusual change. The intention may have been to show that diverse opinions still exist in Russia.

After that, no oligarch came forward to support him. Nevertheless, Prokopenko believes that Melnichenko made these remarks on behalf of fellow businessmen rather than solely his personal opinion.

image copyrightAndrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Some conglomerates may hope that after Putin steps down, Russia will return to what it was like in the 1990s, a so-called 'oligarchy republic', to use the expression of reporter Ostrovsky, where corporate elites held real power.

Based on his experience covering Russia for many years, Ostrovsky said that the majority of Russia's current tycoons "feel that this war has pushed Russia... into a complete dead end, that is, with no future prospects."

But even if oligarchs are thinking about the future, it seems unlikely that they will take action right away.

Browder said many of them are disgruntled but unlikely to take action as long as Putin lives.

“They know that if they challenge Putin, they will be killed by him. Putin is a very paranoid person.”

Mike Calvi, an American financier who was once a major investor in Russia, agreed.

“What can you do other than go to jail or lose your assets? It would be easy for people sitting in London to say, ‘Why doesn’t everyone stand up and act?’ In Russia, if you act, you go straight to jail.”

At one time, Russian oligarchs exercised influence at the highest levels of power. And once Putin is gone, they will no doubt seek to regain their former influence. However, it is questionable whether the remaining forces in the current administration will readily tolerate this.

Learn more

'Silent rich people'... How did Putin get Russian billionaires to stand on his side during the war?

Who are the Russian ‘oligarchy’ facing global sanctions?

Russian oligarch Tinkov: 'This is a massacre and a crazy war'

Russian tycoon says 'Putin mansion' is his

video

Video, 'Nobody was punished' for alleged gang rape at Cornell University, broadcast length 1,34

Video, 'Irreversible water temperature' How hot have the seas of Ulleungdo and Dokdo become, broadcast length 5,34

Video, North Korean defector women talk about dating and sex in North Korea, broadcast length 3,59

Video, from before to after the 'K-pop craze'...the path taken by female musicians, broadcast length 12,14

top news

'What if Putin dies or resigns?' The future that Russian oligarchs are already envisioning

‘There is no postponement of the CSAT’… Ministry of Education 'emergency' as AI fraud continues to spread

'Alice Huang left Megaspeed last year'... Jensen Huang is also moving to return

this time issue

Most viewed news